Step into a unique treasure and slice of Fort Collins history with the beloved "Sure Nuff" House. Built in 1923 as part of a CSU college project and beautifully reimagined by HighCraft Builders in 2020. This 3 bed, 3 bath, 2,426 sq ft raised ranch perfectly blends preserved craftsman charm with modern comfort and luxury. You'll find original red and white oak floors and sunlit rooms that feel both timeless and inviting. You can cozy up to the oversized gas fireplace on those chilly winter nights. Or prepare a delicious meal in your gourmet kitchen. Featuring quartz countertops, a walk-in pantry, an island with additional seating and high-end appliances. Truly a chefs dream! The main floor primary suite offers a serene escape with a spa shower and large walk-in closet. Did I mention all the storage you will find throughout? Not usually a find with a classic home. Downstairs you can relax or entertain with the custom bar, wine cellar and additional rec room. Unwind outdoors on the large front porch or back patio. A 9,500 sq ft organically landscaped lot. Convenient alley access, two oversized detached garages and a storage shed. Updated in 2020 with new paint from Sherwin-Williams' Historical Collection, new roof, full re-wiring, exterior wall insulation and maintained mechanical systems. 812 Peterson Street is truly Old Town Fort Collins living at its most authentic. This home is a MUST see.
Offered By
Missy Eisenach 3035648183, Coldwell Banker Realty- Fort Collins
Lot FeaturesCurbs, Sidewalks, Lawn Sprinkler System, Level
Garage spaces3
Other StructuresStorage
CITYFort Collins
SUBDIVISIONOld Town
COUNTYLarimer
AREAFort Collins
STATECO
SENIOR COMMUNITYNo
TAX AMOUNT5065.0
LATEST UPDATE2025-10-22T16:04:12.071Z
DAYS ON MARKET1
PRICE CHANGE(S)
$1,499,000 Oct 13, 2025
CUMULATIVE DAYS ON MARKET1
Market Trends
New Properties On Market
87
1%
Decrease In New Listings
Average Asking Price
$702,814
$78,938 Decrease In Avg Asking Price
Average Asking Price / Sq. Ft.
$262
$36 Decrease In List Price/Sq. Ft.
Average Days On Market
7
22 Day
Decrease In Days On Market
Data as of Nov 01, 2025.
Remaining statistics above are calculated on activity within the period from Sep 01, 2025 to Oct 31, 2025.
Mortgage Calculator
The information provided by this calculator is for illustrative purposes only and accuracy is not guaranteed. The values and figures shown are hypothetical and may not be applicable to your individual situation. Be sure to consult a financial professional prior to relying on the results. This calculator does not have the ability to pre-qualify you for any mortgage or loan program. Qualification for mortgages or loans requires additional information such as credit scores and existing debts which is not gathered in this calculator. Information such as interest rates and pricing are subject to change at any time and without notice. All information such as interest rates, taxes, insurance, monthly mortgage payments, etc. are estimates and should be used for comparison only.